SVN-REVSION altered when building R-devel out of tree from last snapshot

[Hervé Pagès]

Hi,


Today I downloaded and compiled the last R-devel snapshot.
The SVN-REVISION in the tarball contains the following:

  Revision: 36792
  Last Changed Date: 2005-12-18

But after compiling on Unix (I compiled out of tree), I ended up
with an SVN-REVSION file containing:

  Revision: unknown
  Last Changed Date: Today

in the build tree.

Then when I start R, I get:

  R : Copyright Today, The R Foundation for Statistical Computing
  Version 2.3.0 Under development (unstable) (Today-Today-Today)
  ISBN 3-900051-07-0

even if I naively edit the SVN-REVISION in the build tree before to
start R.

I got this problem on a 64-bit SUSE Linux 9.2, a 32-bit SUSE Linux 9.2
and a Solaris 2.9 sparc system.
On Windows however (where I built R directly in the source tree) I don't
have this problem.

We need to update R-devel on our various build machines in order to test
Bioconductor devel packages with last R-devel and we try to have the exact
same R revision number on every test-machine. Last time I updated R-devel
was 12/01/2005 and I used the same procedure that I am using today but
I didn't have the SVN-REVISION problem.

Also I didn't try to build R-devel from SVN. Maybe this could solve the
problem. It's just that using the tarball was easier to manage.
Anyway I thought it might be worth reporting.

Regards,

Hervé
 

--
------------------------
Hervé Pagès
E-mail: [hidden email]
Phone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]

______________________________________________
[hidden email] mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel

[Martin Maechler]

>>>>> "Herve" == Herve Pages <[hidden email]>
>>>>>     on Mon, 19 Dec 2005 17:10:58 -0800 writes:

    Herve> Hi,
    Herve> Today I downloaded and compiled the last R-devel snapshot.
    Herve> The SVN-REVISION in the tarball contains the following:

    Herve> Revision: 36792
    Herve> Last Changed Date: 2005-12-18

    Herve> But after compiling on Unix (I compiled out of tree),

i.e. "in a separate build directory tree"

    Herve> I ended up with an SVN-REVSION file containing:

    Herve> Revision: unknown
    Herve> Last Changed Date: Today

    Herve> in the build tree.

I can confirm this wrong behavior (Linux Redhat EL4).
There must be something not yet perfect in our 'make' setup
there.  If we are not in the srcdir, we create a 'non-tarball'
file which I think is wrong;  in any case, this is buglet we'll fix.

Thank you, Herve!

    Herve> Then when I start R, I get:

    Herve> R : Copyright Today, The R Foundation for Statistical Computing
    Herve> Version 2.3.0 Under development (unstable) (Today-Today-Today)
    Herve> ISBN 3-900051-07-0

    Herve> even if I naively edit the SVN-REVISION in the build tree before to
    Herve> start R.

    Herve> I got this problem on a 64-bit SUSE Linux 9.2, a 32-bit SUSE Linux 9.2
    Herve> and a Solaris 2.9 sparc system.
    Herve> On Windows however (where I built R directly in the source tree) I don't
    Herve> have this problem.

    Herve> We need to update R-devel on our various build machines in order to test
    Herve> Bioconductor devel packages with last R-devel and we try to have the exact
    Herve> same R revision number on every test-machine. Last time I updated R-devel
    Herve> was 12/01/2005 and I used the same procedure that I

[ you mean 12th of January? ;-)  {yes, it would help to use
  international 2005-12-01 or then Dec 01, 2005}
]

    Herve> am using today but
    Herve> I didn't have the SVN-REVISION problem.

    Herve> Also I didn't try to build R-devel from SVN. Maybe
    Herve> this could solve the problem.

that would definitely solve it, since that's what all of R-core
do "all the time".  
But the way you did, should also work; that's what the tarballs
are for!

    Herve> It's just that using the tarball was easier to manage.
    Herve> Anyway I thought it might be worth reporting.

Definitely.
Thank you again, Hervé !

    Herve> Regards,

    Herve> Hervé
 

    Herve> --
    Herve> ------------------------
    Herve> Hervé Pagès
    Herve> E-mail: [hidden email]
    Herve> Phone: [phone]
    Herve> Fax: [phone]

    Herve> ______________________________________________
    Herve> [hidden email] mailing list
    Herve> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel

______________________________________________
[hidden email] mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel

[Hervé Pagès]

Martin Maechler wrote:

>    Herve> Today I downloaded and compiled the last R-devel snapshot.
>    Herve> The SVN-REVISION in the tarball contains the following:
>
>    Herve> Revision: 36792
>    Herve> Last Changed Date: 2005-12-18
>
>    Herve> But after compiling on Unix (I compiled out of tree),
>
>i.e. "in a separate build directory tree"
>
>    Herve> I ended up with an SVN-REVSION file containing:
>
>    Herve> Revision: unknown
>    Herve> Last Changed Date: Today
>
>    Herve> in the build tree.
>
>I can confirm this wrong behavior (Linux Redhat EL4).
>There must be something not yet perfect in our 'make' setup
>there.  If we are not in the srcdir, we create a 'non-tarball'
>file which I think is wrong;  in any case, this is buglet we'll fix.
>  
>

Hi Martin,

This problem was fixed in today's R-devel tarball
(R-devel_2005-12-20.tar.bz2).
Thanks!

H.

--
------------------------
Hervé Pagès
E-mail: [hidden email]
 Phone: [phone]
   Fax: [phone]

______________________________________________
[hidden email] mailing list
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-devel